Troubleshooting Q & A
Trouble shooting Q & A
  1. Why does my 400A Fill Valve turn on and off by itself without the toilet being flushed?
  2. Why won't my Fill Valve shut off? Why is water continually pouring down the overflow pipe?
  3. Why won't my 400A Fill Valve turn on?
  4. Why is my toilet so noisy while it refills?
  5. Why is my tank filling slowly or not at all?
  6. Why does my 400A Fill Valve leak a small amount of water from the top?
  7. Why do I hear a loud banging of pipes when the valve turns off?
  8. How does a toilet flush?
  9. What are common problem areas?
  10. Are there any quick fixes?
More Troubleshooting Questions and Answers

1. Why does my 400A Fill Valve turn on and off by itself without the toilet being flushed?

(Scroll down to see three possible problems.)

Problem: The Fill Valve's black vinyl refill tube extends too far down the overflow pipe. This creates a siphoning action into the overflow pipe, lowering the tank's water level and causing the valve to turn on and refill tank.
Solution: Make certain the black vinyl refill tube is attached to the top of the overflow pipe with the angle adapter (see illustration). If the angle adapter doesn't fit onto the overflow pipe, Fluidmaster offers a Special Refill Clamp Model 599
Solution: If you don’t have or can’t use an angle adapter, place the black refill tube into the overflow pipe, making sure it rests above the waterline.

Problem: The toilet's tank ball or flapper (see picture) is worn, dirty or misaligned with the flush valve seat, or the seat itself is so corroded that the stopper will not seal properly. This creates a leak that lowers the tank's water level, causing the Valve to turn on and refill the tank.
Solution: Clean tank ball and drain seat thoroughly. If leak persists, replace the worn tank ball or flapper with a Fluidmaster Bull's Eye Flapper Model 500, Bull's Eye Super Flapper Model 501 or a Flusher Fixer Kit Model 555C. The Flusher Fixer Kit includes a plastic replacement seat for damaged brass, plastic or ceramic flush valve drain seats.

Problem: Overflow pipe/flush valve assembly is so corroded it creates leaks that lower the tank's water level, causing the valve to turn on and refill tank.
Solution: Replace the entire overflow pipe/flush valve assembly with a product like Fluidmaster's Flush Valve 507C.

2. Why won't my Fill Valve shut off? Why is water continually pouring down the overflow pipe?

(Scroll down to see four possible problems.)

Problem: Debris is lodged under the valve's seal. Debris may consist of calcium deposits, minute pieces of corroded pipe, rocks, rubber, solder, etc. that are carried by the water stream to the seal area, where they become trapped. Some well systems without a filter constantly circulate debris.
Solution: Shut off the water supply and remove the valve top (Model 400A: lift arm first). Cover the opening with an inverted cup, and turn water on and off a few times. This should flush and remove water line debris. Turn top assembly over and clean seal surface by rinsing under water. Replace top (400A: lift arm first) by rotating clockwise. Turn on water. In the case of well water supplies, the best long-term solution is a filter.

Problem: Valve still will not shut-off after being flushed out using the method above. Valve seal is defective, possibly cracked or split.
Solution: Replace only the seal with a Fluidmaster No. 242 Replacement Seal, available in most stores that carry Fluidmaster valves.

Problem: The water level is set too high and reaches the top of the overflow pipe upon shut-off. This results in small amounts of water pouring into the overflow pipe, causing the valve to turn on to refill the tank.
Solution: Reset tank water to a lower level by using the water level adjustment clip (see illustration) located on the link of the valve. Squeeze the two sides of the metal clip together, then slide clip down the rod.

Problem: Linkage on metal tank lever is corroded and will not allow flapper to close.
Solution: Replace the tank lever with a Fluidmaster Bend/Trim-To-Fit Toilet Tank Flush Lever.

3. Why won't my 400A Fill Valve turn on?

Problem: Cap on top of the valve is not properly locked into place.
Solution: Shut off water supply. Lift arm, then remove valve top by rotating 1/8 turn counterclockwise. Refit top by lifting arm, replacing top and rotating clockwise until locked. Valve won't turn on if top is not fully engaged in the locked position.

Problem: Water supply to toilet may not be on.
Solution: Turn on water supply by turning handle at wall.

4. Why is my toilet so noisy while it refills?

Problem: The angle adapter is pointing straight down the overflow pipe.
Solution: Tilt the angle adapter (see illustration) so the refill water is hitting the inside wall of the overflow pipe.

Problem: Restricted water supply.
Solution: Adjust water supply shut-off valve counterclockwise to open up water flow.

5. Why is my tank filling slowly or not at all?

Problem: Swollen seal.
Solution: Shut off the water supply. Replace only the seal with a Fluidmaster Model 242 Replacement Seal available in most stores that carry Fluidmaster valves.

Problem: Plugged valve inlet or water supply line.
Solution: Shut off water supply. Lift the rod arm and remove top cap assembly by turning 1/8 of a turn counterclockwise. Using a straightened coat hanger, carefully clean out the inlet passage of the valve. Cover the opening of the valve with an inverted cup, and turn water on and off a few times. This should flush and remove water line debris. Turn top assembly over and clean seal surface by rinsing under water. Replace top (400A: lift arm first) by rotating clockwise. Turn on water.

If the problem still persists, you may need to replace your water supply line with Fluidmaster's flexible NO-BURST Braided Stainless Steel Connector, available at local home improvement stores.

6. Why does my 400A Fill Valve leak a small amount of water from the top?

Problem: None. This is normal. When turning on, the valve must vent a small amount of water for the valve to operate.

7. Why do I hear a loud banging of pipes when the valve turns off?

Problem: Not enough air in the right places in water lines. This is often called "water hammer".
Solution: Shut off main water inlet valve to the house. Turn on all water outlet valves inside and outside the house, then flush toilets. Allow outlets to drain and pipes to fill with air. Then turn on main water inlet valve and shut off inside and outside outlet valves. Remove toilet valve top (400A: lift arm first) by rotating 1/8 turn counterclockwise. Hold a container over the uncapped valve and turn water supply on and off a few times to clear debris. Replace top by engaging lugs and rotating 1/8 turn clockwise. Valve may not turn on if the top is not fully turned to the locked position.

8. How does a toilet flush?

When the handle is pressed, the attached lever lifts the flapper by a chain/wire. This opens the flush valve and releases water through the rim into the toilet bowl, where gravity siphons the existing bowl water down the trap.

Once the tank is empty, the flapper drops back onto the flush valve seat, and the fill valve float cup triggers an influx of fresh water into the tank. The fill valve float rises with the water until the preset refill level is reached.

What is a fill valve? Also referred to as a ballcock, the fill valve controls the release of fresh water into the toilet tank. It is attached to a water supply connector through the bottom of the tank.

What is a flush valve? The flapper and drain that controls the discharge of tank water into the toilet bowl. The flapper is aligned over the drain and attached to the overflow pipe.

9. What are common problem areas?


  1. Bent float rod causes overfilling or constant running.
  2. Cracked/leaky float ball creates nonstop leaking into tank.
  3. Noisy or lengthy refill from corroded ballcock.
  4. Misaligned flapper/tank ball (indicated by the need to jiggle the handle).
  5. Warped lift wire hinders correct alignment of tank ball.
  6. Leaks form worn, pitted drain seat.
  7. Corroded tank lever won't properly lift/drop flapper/tank ball.

10. Are there any quick fixes?

These quickie repairs may help for a time, but eventually, the problem will return.

  • Jiggle the handle to reseat the flapper after each flush (controls flapper leak).
  • Straighten a bent lift wire on flapper/tank ball (helps provide a complete flush).
  • Bend the float rod (attached to the float ball) to increase/decrease the tank's water level.

  1. NO-BURST® Fluidmaster Braided Stainless Steel Connector for strength, flexibility.
  2. Sturdy 507 Flush Valve won't corrode.
  3. Bull's Eye® 501 Supper Flapper withstands harsh water.
  4. SURE FIT® Tank Lever, bend/trims to fit.
How a Toilet Flushes Find a Plumber Easy Check for Leaks Where to Find Fluidmaster Products E-mail Prof. Flush